Nautel Radio Coverage Tool

This is a Webinar video from Nautel about their Radio Coverage Tool:

Highlights of the Nautel RF tool kit:

  • Analyze the proposed transmitter location’s coverage
  • Tower heights can be adjusted
  • Antenna gains can be changed
  • Transmitter power levels
  • Includes Terrain data
  • Includes population within coverage areas
  • Frequency Range 30 Mhz to 3GHz
  • Useful for general broadcast or point-to-point systems

This can be a useful tool for those looking to gauge the realistic coverage of a station in terrain-challenged areas.  It can also be useful for studying STL paths, RPU coverage, etc.

One problem is the power levels and antennas are preset, with the minimum setting of 200 watts into a two-bay antenna.  These settings are too high for use when investigating a potential LPFM.  For that, Radio Mobile Online (which is the engine behind the Nautel RF tool kit) can be accessed directly via www.ve2dbe.com/rmonline.html.  Requires an account, which is very easy to set up.  For most users, FM broadcast band frequencies will not be available, however, 2 meter amateur frequencies (146 MHz) are the default, and for all practical purposes, will model coverage in the FM band (88 to 108 MHz) just fine.

By creating a hypothetical LP100 transmitter site, the coverages between the FCC 60 dBu contour and the actual coverage based on terrain can be compared.  This is the FCC 60 dBu coverage contour:

Example contour, LP-100 station
Example 60 dBu contour, LP-100 station

According to the US Census data, this station has a population coverage of; 30,721 in the 70 dBu or 3.162 mV/m contour, 92,574  in the 60 dBu or 1 mV/m contour, and 165,183 in the 50 dBu or 0.316 mV/m contour. Courtesy of REC Network.  The 60 dBu contour is considered the protected area licensed for use by the FCC.

Looking at a coverage terrain map, the picture changes somewhat:

Example coverage map, LP-100 station
Example coverage map, LP-100 station

This is based on predicted receiver location using terrain data; receiver antenna height 1 meter, 90% reliability, minimum signal level 10 µV (20 dBu,  yellow, very good car radios) and 31.62 µV (30 dBu, green, good radios and indoor reception).  Areas to the south and east of the transmitter are shaded by a large hill, thus they show low or no signal on the terrain based coverage map.  UN Population data indicates the yellow has 178,573 and the green area has 72,014 persons.  This map does not take into account co-channel and adjacent channel interference, which there is sure to be.

When comparing the two maps, one can see the coverage holes in the terrain map that are within the 60 dBu contour.  There may also be a slight difference in populations covered because the FCC map uses 2010 US Census data and the Radio Mobile Map uses UN population data.  For general planning purposes, the area shaded in green would be a safe bet on good reception, all other things being equal.

Since the LPFM stations are very limited in their ERP, finding a good transmitter site that will cover the desired area will be key to a successful operation.

Zonecasting; the Technical Details

I saw this item many weeks ago, but, had not had time to look at it until now.  Geo Broadcasting Solutions has filed Petition for Rule Making (RM-11659) based on a system that divides the coverage area of major stations into smaller zones allowing for ad targeting of specific audiences.  They have coined the term “Zone Casting” to describe the scheme. It is covered by two US-issued patents filed by Lazer Spots, LLC: 20120014370 and 20110065377.  After a look at these two patents, it seems there are three possible ways to accomplish this Zone Casting Scheme:

  1. In the first described method, the main transmitter is broadcasting area wide and all the zone transmitters are muted.  An inaudible signal is transmitted to all units, the main transmitter is then muted and the zone transmitters turn on and transmit localized content.  After the local information is transmitted, the zone transmitters mute and the main transmitter resumes broadcasting.
  2. In the second described method, the main transmitter and the zone transmitters are broadcasting area-wide information.  The main transmitter ceases broadcasting area-wide information and the zone transmitters begin broadcasting localized information.  At the end of the localized information, the main transmitter and zone transmitters transmit area-wide information.
  3. In the third describe method, the main transmitter and zone transmitters are broadcasting wide area information with “capture ratio pattern.”  The main transmitter initiates an alteration, temporarily becoming a zone transmitter.  The zone transmitters then transmit localized content.  After the localized content, the main transmitter becomes a main transmitter again.

All of the transmitters are linked to the studio via digital STL systems, and content for the zone transmitters is distributed via IP network.  The transmitter frequencies are synced with GPS, similar to FM on channel booster stations.  Method number three includes possibly switching the transmitter output to a lower gain and or lower height antenna.

Zone Broadcasting Conceptual Diagram
Zone Broadcasting Conceptual Diagram

Of the three methods, the first system will result in the fewest interference issues.  No matter which method is used, there will be interference issues between the zone transmitters and or the main transmitter where the signal strengths are equal and the audio is 180 degrees out of phase.  These can be moved around slightly by adding delay to the audio signal, but they will always be present.  More about Same Frequency Networks (SFN) and Synchronized FM signals can be found here.  While the zone transmitters are transmitting dissimilar localized information, standard capture effect rules apply.

The system has had limited testing in Salt Lake City, Utah (KDUT) and Avon Park, Florida (WWOJ), which according to the filing and comments, went well.

Geo-Broadcasting is applying to conduct a full test with WRMF in Palm Beach, FL.  The expected installation will include up to 22 zone transmitters.

Conceptually, tightly targeted advertising is not a bad idea.  Advertisers like it because they perceive a better return for their dollar.  The cost of such a system is not insignificant. Transmitter site leases run $1-2K per month, leased data lines, equipment, installation work, equipment shelters, etc will likely run several hundred thousand dollars or more.

If it gets approved by the FCC, it will be interesting to see how it works and whether or not the system is financially justifiable.

The Nautel NV-5 Transmitter

We are currently installing this sweet little transmitter:

Nautel NV-5 FM transmitter
Nautel NV-5 FM transmitter

Like its big brother, the NV-40 at WVPS, the NV-5 is a very cool transmitter.  I am a born skeptic, things like touchscreen displays tend to make me a little nervous, especially on a transmitter connected to a 350 feet tall steel tower right next to the transmitter building.  That is the one major difference between WVPS and this site; at Mount Mansfield there are many things between the transmitter and antenna, but in this place, not so much.  Even so,  Nautel makes a good product, so troubles are not expected.

The ground strap, AC power, remote control, and composite audio connections were all made without difficulty.  The result, new transmitter on the air:

Nautel NV-5 FM transmitter GUI
Nautel NV-5 FM transmitter GUI

This unit is analog only, but the information on the spectral display is still useful.  The GUI uses Linux with a touch screen, which is a neat feature.

Nautel NV-5 FM transmitter controller board
Nautel NV-5 FM transmitter controller board

In case the front panel GUI goes out, all transmitter controls can be accessed via push buttons on the remote control interface, which is the small board to the right.  The main controller board is on the left.

Migrating the existing AM stations to former TV channels 5 and 6

This is one of the possibilities that has been bantered about as a solution for the “AM problem.” The theory goes as such; former TV channels 5 and 6 (76 – 88 MHz), which are not suitable for DTV would be an ideal place for the existing AM stations to move.  That represents a 12 MHz chunk of spectrum, which is much more than the current 1.16 MHz spectrum the current AM broadcasting service takes up (.54 to 1.7 Mhz).  An added benefit is that the VHF spectrum does not have the skywave “problem” that the MF spectrum does, thus many more stations could be licensed to the service.  Everyone would benefit, and AM stations would get a new lease on life in the FM band.  The number of stations would increase by several fold, including LPFM, non-commercial, and translators.  AM stations would no longer be burdened with expensive directional arrays or substandard audio quality.

It seems almost too good to be true…

The FCC reportedly promised “take a hard look” at this idea back in 2008.  Four years later, one wonders what has become of it.

A quick search of the existing TV stations licensed to channels 5 and 6 reveals the flaw in this theory.  The FCC has re-licensed many full powered and Low Powered DTV stations to channels 5 and 6 since 2008.

List of full power channel 5 stations:

Call SignServiceStatusCityStateFac IDERP (kw)HAAT (m)Licensee
WOI-DTDTLICAMESIA866113.9566CAPITAL COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY, INC.
WGVKDTLICKALAMAZOOMI2478310169GRAND VALLEY STATE UNIVERSITY
WBKPDTLICCALUMETMI760016.4301LAKE SUPERIOR COMMUNITY BROADCASTING CORPORATION
KXLF-TVDTLICBUTTEMT3595910588KXLF COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
KXGN-TVDTLICGLENDIVEMT242871152.4GLENDIVE BROADCASTING CORP.
KHAS-TVDTLICHASTINGSNE4800345217HOAK MEDIA OF NEBRASKA LICENSE, LLC
WLMBDTLICTOLEDOOH1707610155DOMINION BROADCASTING, INC.
KOBIDTLICMEDFORDOR82606.35823CALIFORNIA OREGON BROADCASTING, INC.
KIVV-TVDTLICLEADSD343489.2561KEVN, INC.
WTVFDTLICNASHVILLETN3650422425NEWSCHANNEL 5 NETWORK, LLC
WMC-TVDTLICMEMPHISTN1918434.5308WMC LICENSE SUBSIDIARY, LLC
KCWXDTLICFREDERICKSBURGTX2431623.7412CORRIDOR TELEVISION, L.L.P.
WCYB-TVDTLICBRISTOLVA245529.9743BLUESTONE LICENSE HOLDINGS INC.
WDTVDTLICWESTONWV7059210240WITHERS BROADCASTING COMPANY OF WEST VIRGINIA
WIWNDTLICFOND DU LACWI605719338WWAZ LICENSE, LLC

List of Low Power Channel 5 stations (analog):

Call SignServiceStatusCityStateFac IDERP (kw)HAAT (m)Licensee
KSCT-LPTXLICSITKAAK153480.0490DAN ETULAIN
K05KFTXLICDILLINGHAMAK7920.160ALASKA CORP OF SEVENTH DAY ADVENTIST
KRDN-LPTXLICREDDINGCA1271790.60KM COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
W05COTXLICSARASOTAFL6699530THREE ANGELS BROADCASTING NETWORK, INC.
W05CJTXLICKEY WESTFL1256420.590JAMES J. CHLADEK
DKHHB-LPTXLICHILOHI12623330KHHB, LLC
WIKY-LPTXLICEVANSVILLE, ETC.IN610360.140ROBERTS BROADCASTING COMPANY OF EVANSVILLE, IN, LLC
K05IVTXLICPARK RAPIDSMN553740.0190RED RIVER BROADCAST CO., LLC
W05BVTXLICSTARKVILLEMS216340.0660FIRST UNITED METHODIST CHURCH
K05LUTXLICJEFFERSON CITYMO1285200.110HISPANIC CHRISTIAN COMMUNITY NETWORK, INC.
K05LYTXLICMOBERLYMO1285600.10HISPANIC CHRISTIAN COMMUNITY NETWORK, INC.
KSXC-LPTXLICSOUTH SIOUX CITYNE12801230VENTURE TECHNOLOGIES GROUP, LLC
K05KYTXLICLINCOLN CITYOR1291902.250MICHAEL MATTSON
K05KXTXLICTILLAMOOKOR1291940.650MICHAEL MATTSON
KRCW-LPTXLICPORTLANDOR351512.70TRIBUNE BROADCAST HOLDINGS, INC., DEBTOR-IN-POSSESSION
K05LETXLICASTORIAOR1291612.50MICHAEL MATTSON
KJIB-LPTXLICCLEAR LAKE CITYTX211840.1030FAR EASTERN TELECASTERS
KLUF-LPTXLICLUFKINTX289370.0940INTERNATIONAL BROADCASTING NETWORK
K05EFTXLICBRADY, ETC.TX100430.0680FOSTER CHARITABLE FOUNDATION, INC.
KTXF-LPTXLICABILENETX1308400.6650KM COMMUNICATIONS, INC.

List of Low Power Channel 5 stations (digital)

Call SignServiceStatusCityStateFac IDERP (kw)HAAT (m)Licensee
K05FW-DLDLICGIRDWOODAK7960.0610ALASKA PUBLIC TELECOMMUNICATIONS, INC.
K05ET-DLDLICLIKELYCA82400.250CALIFORNIA OREGON BROADCASTING, INC.
K05CR-DLDLICHAYFORKCA681120.0070TRINITY COUNTY OFFICE OF EDUCATION
K05CF-DLDLICWEAVERVILLECA713810.0150WEAVERVILLE TRANSLATOR CO., INC.
K05FR-DLDLICCROWLEY LAKECA435120.060MONO COUNTY SERVICE AREA NO. 1
K05DQ-DLDLICBURNEY, ETC.CA83140.0450BLUESTONE LICENSE HOLDINGS INC.
K05LI-DLDLICWEBER CANYONCO1308820.00230SOUTHWEST COLORADO TV TRANSLATOR ASSOCIATION
K05GA-DLDLICDOLORESCO614700.00520SOUTHWEST COLORADO TV TRANSLATOR ASSOCIATION
K05JW-DLDLICISMAY CANYONCO614490.00240SOUTHWEST COLORADO TV TRANSLATOR ASSOCIATION
K05MD-DLDLICCRIPPLE CREEK, ETC.CO1678091.50TUCK PROPERTIES, INC. C/O LEE PELTZMAN
WRUF-LDLDLICGAINESVILLEFL42000.30BOARD OF TRUSTEES, UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA
K05GL-DLDLICCOOLINID535160.0130PRIEST LAKE TRANSLATOR DISTRICT
K05EY-DLDLICTERRACE LAKESID231500.0650GARDEN VALLEY TRANSLATOR DISTRICT
K05BE-DLDLICLEHMI, ETCID587080.0130SALMON TV TRANSLATOR DISTRICT
W05DD-DLDLICST. FRANCISME396520.0970MAINE PUBLIC BROADCASTING CORPORATION
K05GM-DLDLICPLAINS-PARADISEMT527800.0170PLAINS-PARADISE TV DISTRICT
K05AH-DLDLICHOT SPRINGSMT276850.0050HOT SPRINGS TV DISTRICT
K05ML-DLDLICSULAMT1815780.0060SULA TV DISTRICT
K05IZ-DLDLICHINSDALEMT272590.00340HINSDALE TV CLUB
K05MW-DLDLICFERNDALEMT1825480.0240SWAN HILL TV DIST
K05FC-DLDLICLAKE MCDONALDMT167540.0050CANYON TV
K05KK-DLDLICPOPLARMT530120.0370POPLAR TV DISTRICT
K05JU-DLDLICELKONV194010.10ELKO TELEVISION DISTRICT
K05AF-DLDLICMINA/LUNINGNV427020.070MINERAL TELEVISION DISTRICT #1
W05AR-DLDLICBRYSON CITY, ETC.NC538960.0890WYFF HEARST TELEVISION INC.
WTVFLDLICNASHVILLETN3650430NEWSCHANNEL 5 NETWORK, LLC
K05AR-DLDLICROCKVILLEUT709620.0310BONNEVILLE INTERNATIONAL CORPORATION
W05AW-DLDLICCHRISTIANSTEDVI702860.30VIRGIN ISLANDS PUBLIC TV SYSTEM
W05AA-DLDLICROANOKEVA739890.0970WSET, INCORPORATED
K05MU-DLDLICLEAVENWORTHWA1875400.010LEAVENWORTH NON-PROFIT TV ASSOCIATION
KCEM-LDLDLICCHELAN BUTTEWA644550.0030APPLE VALLEY TV ASSOCIATION, INC

List of full power Channel 6 stations:

Call SignServiceStatusCityStateFac IDERP (kw)HAAT (m)Licensee
WUOADTLICTUSCALOOSAAL7749626395THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE UNIVERSITY OF AlABAMA
WEDYDTLICNEW HAVENCT135950.488CONNECTICUT PUBLIC BROADCASTING, INC.
WCES-TVDTLICWRENSGA239377.9429.4GEORGIA PUBLIC TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
WABW-TVDTLICPELHAMGA2391710.5378.9GEORGIA PUBLIC TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
KBSD-DTDTLICENSIGNKS6641431216.8SUNFLOWER BROADCASTING, INC.
KTVM-TVDTLICBUTTEMT1806619.2591.3BLUESTONE LICENSE HOLDINGS INC.
KWNB-TVDTLICHAYES CENTERNE2116211.9221PAPPAS TELECASTING OF CENTRAL NEBRASKA, L.P.
WRGBDTLICSCHENECTADYNY7394230.2392WRGB LICENSEE, LLC
WPVI-TVDTLICPHILADELPHIAPA861634330ABC, INC.

List of  Low Power Channel 6 stations (analog):

Call SignServiceStatusCityStateFac IDERP (kw)HAAT (m)Licensee
K06LGTXLICCHUATHBALUKAK628270.0520STATE OF ALASKA
K06LPTXLICCIRCLE HOT SPRINGSAK625290.5480STATE OF ALASKA
KNIK-LPTXLICANCHORAGEAK214920.920FIREWEED COMMUNICATIONS LLC
K06MFTXLICKENAI, ETC.AK214901.440FIREWEED COMMUNICATIONS LLC
W06BHTXLICPHENIX CITY, ETC.AL252070.060GREENE COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
KNJO-LPTXLICHOLBROOKAZ1311620.4750KM COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
KVFA-LPTXLICYUMAAZ1311440.050KM COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
K06MUTXLICBIG BEAR LAKECA6314910BEAR VALLEY BROADCASTING, INC.
KNNN-LPTXLICREDDINGCA1292491.50VENTURE TECHNOLOGIES GROUP, LLC
KLOA-LPTXLICINYOKERN, ETC.CA2858330ROBERT D. ADELMAN
KCIO-LPTXLICVICTORVILLECA115290.990OBIDIA PORRAS
KRPE-LPTXLICBANNINGCA1296510.9990VENTURE TECHNOLOGIES GROUP, LLC
KUHD-LPTXLICVENTURACA679630.9990OBIDIA PORRAS
KBKF-LPTXLICSAN JOSECA1278820.60VENTURE TECHNOLOGIES GROUP, LLC
KEFM-LPTXLICSACRAMENTOCA12799630VENTURE TECHNOLOGIES GROUP, LLC
KXDP-LPTXLICDENVERCO6755230SYNCOM MEDIA GROUP, INC.
WHDY-LPTXLICPANAMA CITYFL13006310CONFESORA PERALTA
WEYS-LPTXLICMIAMIFL603530ALMAVISION HISPANIC NETWORK
WDDA-LPTXLICDALTONGA1311272.50WORD OF GOD FELLOWSHIP, INC.
KESU-LPTXLICHANAMAULUHI13100530CHANG BROADCASTING HAWAII, LLC
WKQX-LPTXLICCHICAGOIL12823930WLFM, LLC
W06BDTXLICPRINCETONIN492430.0140NORTH GIBSON SCHOOL CORPORATION
WDCO-LPTXLICSALISBURYMD13043910SIGNAL ABOVE LLC
WJMF-LPTXLICJACKSONMS2625320KID’S TELEVISION, LLC
KGHD-LPTXLICLAS VEGASNV13002730OBIDIA PORRAS
WMYH-LPTXLICELMIRANY1258190.250VISION COMMUNICATIONS, LLC
WXXW-LPTXLICBINGHAMTONNY1292240.0160JOHNSON BROADCASTING COMPANY, INC.
WNYZ-LPTXLICNEW YORKNY5604330ISLAND BROADCASTING LLC
WMBO-LPTXLICWESTVALENY143190.30METRO TV, INC.
WNNY-LPTXLICAUBURNNY413641.450RENARD COMMUNICATIONS CORP.
WMTO-LPTXLICWANCHESENC1278020.60RAY H. LIVESAY
WLFM-LPTXLICCLEVELANDOH669930VENTURE TECHNOLOGIES GROUP, LLC
K06NITXLICTHE DALLESOR1291530.250MICHAEL MATTSON
WRTN-LPTXLICALEXANDRIATN12585820RICHARD C & LISA A. GOETZ
WPGF-LPTXLICMEMPHISTN2384830GEORGE S. FLINN, JR.
KRGT-LPTXLICRIO GRANDE CITYTX579990.040CTV BROADCASTING, LLC
KFMP-LPTXLICLUBBOCKTX12973430VENTURE TECHNOLOGIES GROUP, LLC
KXIT-LPTXLICAMARILLOTX13008930GEORGE CHAMBERS
KBFW-LPTXLICARLINGTONTX12788730GERALD BENAVIDES
KZFW-LPTXLICDALLASTX531630DFW BROADCASTING, INC.
K06PBTXLICUVALDETX673030.990SUPER RADIO, INC.
WDCN-LPTXLICFAIRFAXVA2045030SIGNAL ABOVE LLC
K06OATXLICEAU CLAIREWI1291390.90MARCIA T. TURNER D/B/A TURNER ENTERPRISES

List of Low Power Channel 6 stations  (digital):

Call SignServiceStatusCityStateFac IDERP (kw)HAAT (m)Licensee
K06OR-DLDLICSEWARDAK1688660.30SEWARD MEDIA PARTNERS, LLC
K06AE-DLDLICPRESCOTTAZ352740.50MULTIMEDIA HOLDINGS CORPORATION
K06HN-DLDLICGUNNISONCO256110.060GUNNISON COUNTY METROPOLITAN RECREATION DISCRICT
K06HU-DLDLICASPENCO567040.0060PITKIN COUNTY TRANSLATOR DEPARTMENT
K06GW-DLDLICNEW CASTLECO231590.0050ROCKY MOUNTAIN PUBLIC BROADCASTING NETWORK, INC
K06NT-DLDLICDOLORESCO1308810.00520SOUTHWEST COLORADO TV TRANSLATOR ASSOCIATION
K06NG-DLDLICSARGENTSCO1269290.050GUNNISON COUNTY METROPOLITAN RECREATION DISCRICT
W06AY-DLDLICLEBANONKY704980.30GARY WHITE
K06FE-DLDLICMILES CITYMT357260.10MMM LICENSE II LLC
K06AA-DLDLICBROADUSMT531670.0880POWDER RIVER T.V. BOARD
K06AV-DLDLICWOLF POINTMT733760.0190WOLF POINT TV DISTRICT
K06NV-DLDLICWHITE SULPHUR SPRINGSMT217100.060MEAGHER COUNTY TELEVISION DISTRICT
K06JC-DLDLICCHADRONNE479770.0660NEBRASKA EDUCATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
K06KR-DLDLICCRAWFORDNE479910.0280NEBRASKA EDUCATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS COMMISSION
K06PG-DLDLICLAUGHLINNV116870.30CLARK COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT
K06KQ-DLDLICMANHATTANNV141260.020COUNTY OF NYE
K06MK-DLDLICELKONV193800.10ELKO TELEVISION DISTRICT
K06HT-DLDLICELYNV591290.0530WHITE PINE TELEVISION DISTRICT # 1
K06NY-DLDLICRYNDONNV1287500.0620ELKO TELEVISION DISTRICT
W06AJ-DLDLICFRANKLIN, ETC.NC538840.1930WYFF HEARST TELEVISION INC.
K06NS-DLDLICCHILOQUINOR82680.1930CALIFORNIA OREGON BROADCASTING, INC.
K06PM-DLDLICBEAUMONTTX1288360.30ROGER MILLS
K06JA-DLDLICCEDAR CANYONUT97120.0150CEDAR CANYON TV

Looking through this data, particularly the digital licenses which were granted since 2009, one an only assume that the FCC has, by de facto, nixed this idea if it ever considered it at all.