FM – Engineering Radio

The Alford Antenna

I have been doing a bit of work in this building recently.

5th Avenue Lobby, Empire State Building, New York, NY

Therefore, when I saw the opportunity to acquire a piece of NYC radio history, I took it. The SBE Ennes Workshops are designed to bring affordable education to the Broadcast Engineering community. One major problem in the Broadcast Engineering field is the aging workforce. Any resource that can spur interest by younger people is important. Named after Harold E. Ennes, the Ennes Educational Foundation Trust funds scholarships, workshops, seminars, and helps underwrite the costs of producing text books. Making a donation by bidding on an element of the Alford antenna was an easy decision.

The Alford antenna was manufactured and installed in 1965 on the 102 story observation deck of the Empire State Building. It was designed by Andrew Alford, an electrical engineer, who designed antennas for ILS and VOR aviation navigation systems. It is the first purpose build combined FM master antenna system in the world. Both the antenna and combiner system were novel ideas at the time.

The master antenna was becoming a necessity because the spire and tower on top of the Empire State building had become over crowded with FM and TV antennas. In the 1931, RCA/NBC leased the 85th floor of the ESB for their development laboratory.

Circa 1936, RCA television transmitter on 85th floor, from the Early Television Museum

Once both services became commercial, the FCC forced RCA/NBC to allow other FM and TV stations to locate on the building.

According to the IEEE paper written about it, the idea of a master antenna came about in 1959. It was not until the mid 1960’s that the first three stations agreed to the idea.

The requirements for the new antenna included:

1) System should accept the output of seventeen different FM station transmitters at a power level of 10 kW each.
2) The antenna should radiate an essentially omnidirectional signal in both horizontal and vertical polarizations in approximately equal amounts.
3) The antenna gain and multiplexer losses should be such that each station can achieve an ERP of approximately 5.5 kW in both polarizations (the maximum power presently authorized by the FCC for that height above ground and that location).
4) The antenna system should be well matched over the entire frequency band from at least 92 to 108 MHz and preferably from 88to 108 MHz.
5) The external portions of the antenna should be deiced.
6) System VSWR should be 1.1 or less at each station’s input over a 200 kHz band centered at each station’s carrier frequency.
7) Isolation between antenna and other antennas on building should be at least 40 dB.
8) Isolation between FM transmitters connected to the system should be at least 40 dB for adjacent FM carrier frequencies and at least 36 dB for non-adjacent FM carrier frequencies.
9) The frequency-phase characteristic of the system as measured at each station’s input should be linear within ±50 throughout a 200 kHz band centered at each station’s carrier frequency.
10) System should allow for any number of stations to participate at the beginning and should allow for additional stations to be added from time to time as required up to a maximum of seventeen in any arbitrary order of carrier frequencies.

IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON BROADCASTING, VOL. BC-13, NO. 3, JULY 1967, The Empire State Building Master FM Antenna.

That article is an interesting read.

This is one of 32 elements of that antenna. It was in position 10L, according to the name plate. Date of manufacture was 7-65. It is 81.28 x 139.7 x 13.9 cm (32 x 55 x 5.5 inches) and weighs about 45 KG (100 lbs). The RF input is 1 5/8 inch EIA flange, located in the middle of the mounting plate.

Of course, the covers had to come off so I could see what was inside. The antenna is cast from non-magnetic (AKA stainless) steel. The elements were installed with the covers down, as they are not water proof and have weep holes to allow condensation to drain out of the element.

Inside contains the resistance heating element. Interestingly, the return wire for the element is tied to ground and does not have an insulated path to neutral. Each return wire was burned open, meaning that at least this antenna element had no heaters. In the northeast, that will certainly lead to problems.

I wonder if that was one of the reasons to replace it with a new master antenna. Other reasons would be that newer antennas have better circular polarization, more even signal pattern giving better reception, better gain characteristics, better combining systems with more isolation and the ability to pass HD Radio side bands, etc.

No doubt, this antenna section will end up in my radio room, but I am still working on how I will display this interesting piece.

The Pace Accelerates

Update 2: The picture above is the former side of WUPE-AM 1110 KHz, Pittsfield, MA. On March 27, 2025 the license was cancelled upon request of the owner.

Update: I decided to to a major edit to this post due to an error in the FCC’s LMS showing more stations as Licensed and Silent than there actually are. Here is a screen shot from the LMS showing most of Audacy’s AM licenses as “Licensed and Silent.”

Regarding the Audacy AM licenses, A little more research shows that they filled for MDCL on April 10th.

WFAN Licensed and Silent, MDCL applied for

Someone at the FCC must have confused “Licensed but coverage area reduced,” with “Licensed and Silent.” It is an easy mistake to make or it is some sort of late April Fools joke. They are now properly listed as “Licensed.”

There are 116 AM stations listed as licensed and silent.

As of this writing, there are 103 full power FM stations and 46 Low Power FM stations in the LMS listed as licensed and silent.

Reading various sources about AM and FM licenses being taken silent around the country. Often, after 12 months, these licenses are quietly surrendered to the FCC. I thought it would be interesting to see exactly how many stations are now deleted.

In the last 12 months the FCC has deleted:

60 full power AM licenses
20 full power FM licenses
53 Low Power FM license
28 FM translators

60 Full power AM licenses deleted in one year is a record.

Sometimes, I get the feeling that licenses that could be sold are instead surrendered because the current owner does not want new competition. Given the shrinking pool of potential advertizers, this makes a little bit of sence. This is a thing we see in American business culture, sort of the “Walmartization” of various business sectors. In other cases, the facility is in such bad shape that it would be cost prohibative to bring it back.

A few people have suggested that once a license is deleted, the allotment can be resurrected and applied for. That is not a bad idea with some caveats for AM class C, D, and FM low power stations. If there is any loosening of broadcast regulation, particularly in AM antenna design, community coverage contours, city of license requirements, and so on, then this could be a way to get more interest in the AM band.

The General Electric T1000C Stereo Receiver

My parents had one of these units on the side table in the dining room. My father put up an FM antenna outside on the roof so he could listen to more stations. In the early 1960s, there were not as many around as there are today. Our house was on the wrong side of a hill for the NYC stations, although Peekskill seemed to come in just fine. What is fascinating to me is the timing and cost. These stereos were made in 1963, not long after the Zenith/General Electric FM stereo system was adopted and first broadcast on WGFM (now WRVE) in Schenectady, NY (June 1, 1961). Not every FM station rushed out to install the new system.

General Electric T1000C Stereo receiver marketing

For a bit of a reference, $180.00 in 1963 is worth $1,868.65 in 2025. At that time, my father was an installer/repairman for New York Telephone. My mother was not working and six of us lived under one roof. That was quite a bit of money for an AM/FM radio.

The radio was normally tuned to 100.7 WHUD, which initially went stereo in 1972. Other stations that could be received: WGFM, WROW-FM, WSPK, WEOK-FM (now WPDH), and WGFH (later WINE-FM now WRKI).

General Electric T1000C stereo (Walnut cabinet)

I purchased this one on eBay for $70.00. It turns on (in fact, it did not turn off), there is a hum, the pots are scratchy, etc. However, if I tune it to one of the local AM stations, I can hear music under the loud 60-cycle hum. In other words, it works! So, I spent time fixing all the defects and enjoyed some nostalgia. According to this date stamp, the wood enclosure was made in January 1963. I would think the rest of the unit was made about the same time, which means this is one of the first radios in this model. This may have been manufactured in Bridgeport, CT, or Syracuse, NY. The serial number is missing from the back of the chassis.

The main source of the hum appears to be this capacitor, which clearly has seen better days.

The on/off problem was the selector switch, which stuck in the on position because it was gunked up with dried-up lubricating oil and dust. I cleaned it with denatured alcohol and DeOxit.

The parts list included about $15 worth of capacitors, $1 for a new rectifier diode, a $7 telescoping FM antenna from Amazon, and $6.32 for two PLT 12 6.3 volt miniature lamps for dial light.

All of the tubes look to be the original GE units. After the recap, I turned it on and there was nice sounding AM, but no FM. The FM RF section has a triple triode (V2) which is the AFC, 10.7 MHz Oscillator, and mixer. This tube was loose in its socket and needed to be reseated. After that, everything worked.

All of the pots were scratchy. I cleaned them with DeOxit and worked them back and forth many times. After a while, they all are working.

FM Stereo receiver MPX decoder block diagram

I found a Sam’s Photofact (basic service manual) on this set. What is very interesting is the schematic for the multiplex receiver. This section decodes the L+R/L-R signals and produces the stereo audio. Unlike modern FM stereo receivers, in which the broadband multiplex signal is fed into one side of a chip and the discrete L/R signal comes out of the other side, the signal path through the various processing stages can be followed.

The broadband MPX signal comes from the IF stage via wire #27. The signal is amplified by V6. The L+R (20 Hz to 15 KHz) or mono signal goes through a low-pass filter L17/C40; the 3dB cutoff should be around 16-17 KHz. The L-R and 19 KHz pilot goes to wire 34, thence through a high-pass filter C37/L16/C38; the cutoff should be 20 KHz or so. The L-R and 19 KHz pilot are Amplitude Modulated subcarriers on the FM signal. Wire 38 routes the MPX signal to V6 which recreates the 38 KHz subcarrier by doubling the 19 KHz pilot. This is filtered by a bandpass filter C13/L14. The L-R and the 38 KHz subcarrier are sent to the product detector.

Diode product detectors X4 and X5 (1N541) demodulate the lower sideband (23 – 37.98 KHz) and the upper side band (38.02 – 53 KHz) respectively. Those signals are summed in the matrix subassembly K4 with the L+R. Mathematically, the results are:

The Left and Right audio is then sent to the first audio stage V7 through a deemphasis network. If no 19 KHz pilot is detected, no 38 KHz carrier is recreated and this stage remains silent. In other words, you have to find an FM station in mono first, then flip it to stereo to see if there is enough signal to decode the L-R. One of the limitations of the first generation of FM stereo receivers. Newer versions of this set have a stereo light, or “Stereo Eye” so the listener knows when stereo reception is possible.

The front of the cabinet is covered with glass, which I cleaned with soapy water. The glass has part of the gold leaf trim rubbed off. I think this radio got a lot of use.

I let the knobs soak in soapy water overnight then cleaned them off with an old toothbrush. I believe that this radio was once in a smoking environment, based on the amount of yellow, gooey substance covering everything. I ended up disassembling the entire unit to clean it. I used a paintbrush and the shop vac to get all of the dust out of the cabinet.

The speakers and speaker cones are in good condition. The speaker cabinets needed a little work; in both cabinets, the fronts (the part that is seen when both speakers are “closed”) were popping off. I had to glue a bit of wood back together and fix the metal holding brackets. The cloth on the speaker side is a little faded.

General Electric T1000C restoration complete

The wood finish is in good shape with a few scratches and dings. I decided to use Howard Restore-A-Finish. This is not the same as stripping and refinishing but rather repairing the existing finish. There was a water ring on top of the cabinet, which was removed with the Restore-A-Finish and light use of steel wool.

Three power supply capacitors, held down by a ty-base glued to the chassis

Reassembly went about as expected. I glued these tie bases to hold up the new capacitors.

The receiver is fairly sensitive and the dial is accurate. There is an alignment procedure in the repair manual, but I think everything is working as it should. I have spent enough time trying to fix things that are already working to know that for a 1963 tube receiver, this is good enough. Perfection, as they say, is the enemy of everything else.

So, how does it sound? Pretty darn good, as it turns out. I am working on a brief YouTube video with some religious music (I’ll post it when it is done). On the FM side, I can get WAMK, WBPM, WKXP, WJUX, WDST, WPDH, WFSO, and WPDA clearly with the whip antenna on the radio. AM, I hear WGHQ and WJIP.

I can hear the old man now, humming along to his favorite tune…

The Bext TFC2K broadband FM antenna

FM Broadband antennas are a compromise because they generally have less gain than tuned antennas, are more complicated, and take up more space. However, this antenna has none of those issues. The gain and radiation pattern appears to be almost the same as a tuned three-bay FM antenna.

We are finishing up an antenna project in Pittsfield, MA, this week.

The project involved replacing a Shively 6812 tuned to 95.9 MHz (WBEC-FM) with the TFC2K so that the W277CJ 103.3 MHz (WUPE) translator located on the roof of the 14-story Holiday Inn on West Street could be moved to the studio location. In this case, having the translator in-house will save significant rent. The new antenna will continue to serve as a backup facility for WBEC-FM when the main site is off the air for whatever reason.

The input power per bay is based on the antenna’s input connector. In this case, each bay has a 7-16 DIN connector and the power divider is a 7/8 inch EIA flange. Thus the maximum input power for this setup is 5.5 KW. The licensed output for both facilities is far below that.

According to the manual, this antenna should be spaced at 0.85 wavelength, which is frequency-dependent. I chose a frequency halfway between the two (103.3 – 95.9)/2+95.9 = 99.5 MHz. The formula from the Bext general antenna manual is:

D = (300/F) x 0.85

Where
D = the distance between center of radiating elements (booms)
F - Frequency in Mhz.

Thus, D = (300/99.5) x 0.85 = 2.56 meters (or 8′ 5″)

As this is a series excited AM tower, some type of broadband isolation coil is needed to cross the base insulator. This one is simply a large coil of 7/8 inch coax, likely with a capacitor across the outer conductor to create a resonant LC network.

To me, it looks like a water heater. Since the ground is frozen solid, we made a temporary stand. We will have to come back in the spring to create a permanent stand or perhaps a unistrut mount to the wall of the ATU building.

In the rack room, the transmitters are combined into a Bext FDCSDC2 star point combiner.

Broadband sweep shows a good match across the entire FM band. I will be interested to see how it performs with respect to the Shively single bay 6812 on the roof of the hotel (103.3 W277CJ).

Return loss, Bext TFC2K 3 bay FM antenna

The return loss looks good on both 95.9 and 103.3 MHz. The interference noted in the sweep is from local FM stations including the main transmitter for 95.9 MHz.