AM radio sucks! It’s horrible, sounds terrible and should be turned off!

This is a youtube video of a Police song from the 1980s received via skywave and recorded off-air on an AM radio.

Video Description:

The classic 1983 #1 smash hit, as received in analog C-Quam AM Stereo… in Japan… via nighttime skywave in the Tokyo area, roughly 500 miles away from Sapporo (ed: where the station is located). The audio quality is among the best I’ve ever heard from analog AM radio, thanks in large part to an excellent wideband receiver, very quiet band conditions, and the Orban Optimod-AM 9100 audio processor being used by HBC Radio to its maximum extent: 12.5 kHz audio bandwidth with stereo enhancement added (above and beyond the amount naturally provided by the matrix processing used by AM Stereo).

Absolute trash, I tell you. Just awful.

Of course, I know several FM stations around here that wished they sounded as good. Naturally, Japan, they have sought to minimize night-time interference problems by limiting the number of stations on the air and enforcing the rules and regulations in place to protect those stations on the air. They also seem to allow greater bandwidth, out to 12.5 KHz in spite of the narrower channel allocations (9 KHz in ITU regions I and III, vs 10 KHz here in the US, ITU region II). One other thing to note, there is no digital buzz saw occupying several channels of the broadcast spectrum. Keep in mind, this was received in Tokyo, likely a very high noise environment.

I was trying to find out the power level of the transmitter, the call sign is JOHR in Sapporo Japan, frequency is 1287 KHz. HBC is the Hokkaido Broadcasting Company, a privately held company. The state-run radio outlets in Japan are NHK, which has several radio and TV stations throughout the islands.

Anyway, AM is dead. Killed by the very owners of the broadcasting companies themselves with help from the NAB. They are the ones that petitioned the FCC to loosen up the allocations and allow more and more stations to be crammed into the band. That is old news. The new news is same forces that killed AM radio are diligently working their magic on the FM band as well. More stations, translators, digital IBOC nonsense that doesn’t work, more of everything. After all, more is better. Until it is not. Then it’s too late.

AM HD update and other ideas

Looks like the AM HD Radio™ juggernaut continues… To sink under its own technical faults that is. According to the list the number of AM stations running IBOC in the US is now down to 233 stations from a high water mark of 290 or so.  That represents a total of just 4.8% (233 IBOC/4782 Total stations) of all US AM radio stations.  On a related note, Bob Savage of WYSL 1040, Rochester, NY has a good idea:

I’ve always said – if you want to see surprising new life in the AM band, s**t-can the stupid irrelevant NRSC pre-emphasis filter and allow stations to run to 15 kHz during daylight hours and 10 kHz nighttime.  Mandate C-QUAM in all receiver and receiver devices.

It will sound better than HD, be more robust, and cause far fewer problems.  Plus it wouldn’t obsolete a single radio out there, while making a whole bunch of them sound a whole bunch better.

It is so simple in concept, so easy to implement, with almost no expense to AM stations.  Again, Mr. Savage:

Most software-based processors have com ports which can be addressed by a remote control system like Sine Systems, so when the power gets reduced at evening pattern change, the bandpass can be changed at the same time…..vice-versa at sunup.  No biggie.

For older setups a simple outboard relay and rolloff network could accomplish the same thing.  It’s a little more complex but again, not a big deal.

Wow.  Facepalm.

Wish somebody had thought of that a few years ago, it might have saved several million dollars and we’d have a different AM band today.

There are a few shoehorned AM stations around here that might be adversely affected by 15 KHz daytime bandwidth, but those are few and far between.  By and large, most stations are spaced correctly where this could really work and work well.  It certainly would not generate the chaos that AM HD Radio™ has.

What is 200 KHz divided by 400 KHz?

The standard FM channel in the United States, as defined by the FCC is 200 KHz (See CFR 47  73.201).  The occupied bandwidth of an FM IBOC signal, as created by Ibiquity, Inc., is 400 KHz.  See the below picture:

HD radio trace on FSH3 Spectrum Analyzer
HD radio trace on FSH3 Spectrum Analyzer

A picture is worth a thousand words. Engineering types will understand this without explanation. For non-engineering types, here are your thousand words (or so):

On the left-hand side of the screen is the signal strength scale.  Each vertical division is 10 dB.  This is not absolute signal strength, it is referenced to -20 dBm.  However, it gives a good relative signal strength for both the analog carrier and the IBOC carriers.  The analog carrier is centered on the screen, it slopes upward like a steep mountain, peaking at -50 dBm relative.  The IBOC carriers are on either side of the analog carrier, they are flat, approximately 75 KHz wide, and peak approximately 20 dBm below the analog carrier (-20 dBc).  For some reason, likely the bandwidth and/or impedance match between the antenna, high-level combiner and the two transmitters, the left IBOC carrier is actually peaking around -14 dBc.

The span, as noted on the bottom right-hand side of the screen is 500 kHz.  Each horizontal division is 50 KHz.  The entire span of the measurable signal is eight horizontal divisions, thus 400 KHz.

As noted above, the allocated channel bandwidth is 200 KHz, thus this station is exceeding it’s allocated bandwidth by 100%.  This is allowed under CFR 73.404, which is titled “Interim hybrid IBOC DAB operation.”

IBOC proponents will make the argument that FM radios work on something called “The capture effect,” which is to say that if two signals are on or close to the same frequency, only the stronger signal will be demodulated.  Thus, the IBOC carriers have no effect on the adjacent channels that they are interfering with so long as the adjacent signal is stronger than the IBOC carrier.  The argument is further carried forward by assuming that with a station’s protected contour (60 dBu in most cases), the IBOC carrier will never exceed that analog carrier.

That is not necessarily true, especially in areas where terrain (and buildings, underpasses, unintentional directionality in transmitting antenna, etc) can attenuate signals close in causing the IBOC signal to become equal to or stronger than the adjacent analog signal.  This effect causes picket fencing.  Lower powered FM stations; class A, LPFM, etc, are especially vulnerable to this effect.

Further, even in areas where the analog carrier is stronger than the IBOC carrier, the noise floor has been moved from -100 dBm or so to -70 dBm, which is a 1,000 times greater.  To assume that raising the noise floor by 1,000 times will have no effect is, as they used to say in the Navy, making an ASS out of U and ME.  Mostly you, in this case.  This affects the receiver by making it less sensitive, it will also add noise to the demodulated signal as the elevated noise floor will show up as background hiss.  Even further still, higher IBOC carrier levels, as authorized by the FCC in January of 2010 can interfere with the station’s own analog carrier.

According to both Ibiquity and the FCC, which stated in the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking, the reason for interim IBOC operations are:

iBiquity’s IBOC DAB technology provides for enhanced sound fidelity, improved reception, and new data services. IBOC is a method of transmitting near-CD quality audio signals to radio receivers along with new data services such as station, song and artist identification, stock and news information, as well as local traffic and weather bulletins. This technology allows broadcasters to use their current radio spectrum to transmit AM and FM analog signals simultaneously with new higher quality digital signals. These digital signals eliminate the static, hiss, pops, and fades associated with the current analog radio system. IBOC was designed to bring the benefits of digital audio broadcasting to analog radio while preventing interference to the host analog station and stations on the same channel and adjacent channels. IBOC technology makes use of the existing AM and FM bands (In-Band) by adding digital carriers to a radio station‘s analog signal, allowing broadcasters to transmit digitally on their existing channel assignments (On-Channel) iBiquity IBOC technology will also allow for radios to be ”backward and forward” compatible, allowing them to receive traditional analog broadcasts from stations that have yet to convert and digital broadcasts from stations that have converted. Current analog radios will continue to receive the analog portions of the broadcast.

Few if any of those goals have been met.  As far as the forward/backward compatible thing, it just isn’t so unless a person actually owns an HD Radio.  As noted in previous posts, few consumers have seen fit to purchase an HD Radio, nor have car manufacturers taken to installing them en mass in new cars, so there is no forward compatibility.  Instead, we have FM radio stations interfere with each other and themselves in an attempt to “modernize” the audio broadcasting business.  This is a bigger problem for small, community radio stations that can neither afford to install the expensive, proprietary HD Radio system nor broadcast quality receivable signals with an adjacent HD Radio signal raising the noise floor by 1,000 times or more.

I can think of no other greater threat to free over-the-air broadcasting than HD Radio and the degradation of AM and FM services that come with it.  The consumer has shown that they don’t care.  If given the choice between free over-the-air broadcasting that has mediocre programming and is full of interference, and some type of paid internet streaming service that sounds reasonable with good programming, they’ll go for the latter.

In short, some cobbed-together digital modulation scheme is the last thing that radio needs right now.

AM IBOC turn offs?

I have received an e-mail from occasional reader John, who comments that many of the Windy City AMs have turned their buzz saws off. I note today, that the same can be said for many of the NYC AMs.  WABC has had its IBOC turned off for quite some time.  The latest to turn off is WNYC on 820 KHz.  Several people have noted the loss of noise on their signal this morning.

According to Ibiquity’s own website, only six AM stations in the NYC market are currently using IBOC.

What does this mean?

Could it be that management is finally realizing that the cure is worse than the disease?  The disease is alleged poor audio quality, and the cure is IBOC itself.