As broadcasters, we don’t really hear that much about ceramic power vacuum tubes these days, as more and more broadcast transmitters migrate to solid state devices. Once upon a time, however, power tubes where the engine that drove the entire operation. Tubes had to be budgeted for, stocked, rotated and replaced on a regular schedule. Some of those dern things were expensive too.
Take the 4CX35,000A which was used in the Harris MW50 transmitters. The transmitter used two of these tubes, one in the RF section and one it the modulator. As I recall, new tubes cost somewhere north of $8,000.00 each from EIMAC. Plus, in the A models there were two 4CX1500A driver tubes. All of which could add up to an expensive maintenance cost every two years or so.
The next best option was to buy rebuilt tubes. Rebuilt tubes were about half the cost of brand new ones. Some people complain that rebuilds don’t last as long, or only last half as long as the new tubes. I never found that to be the case. I often found other factors effected tube life far greater, such as filament voltage management, cooling and by extension, cleanliness.
I can say I never had a warranty issue with ECONCO tubes. I cannot say that about EIMAC, as during the late 90′s and early 00′s (or whatever you call that decade) I had several brand new 4CX3500 tubes that were bad right out of the box. These days, ECONCO and EIMAC are both owned by CPI.
I spoke with John Canevari from ECONCO who had a lot of information. For example, as the tube ages, the filament gets more flexible, not less. Most ceramic power tubes use a carbonized tungsten filament containing some small amount of thorium. As the tube ages, the filament can no longer boil off enough electrons and the emission begins to drop off. That is the normal end of life for a power tube. Occasionally, some catastrophic failure will occur.
There are many steps in the rebuilding process:
- Dud is received from the field, the serial number is recorded and the tube is tested in.
- The tube is prepped by sand blasting the sealing rings
- It is opened
- Filament is replaced. In 60-70% of the cases, the grid is replaced. In those tubes that have a screen assembly, 20-60% of those will be replaced.
- Interior of the tube is cleaned
- Tube is resealed and tested for leaks with a gas spectrometer
- Tube is placed on the vacuum machine. Tubes are evacuated hot, smaller tubes take 12 to 24 hours, very large tubes can take up to one week.
- The tube is nipped off of the vacuum while still hot. When the tube is fully cooled the vacuum scale is normally around 10-12
- Exterior of tube is cleaned and replated. Silver for tubes that are socketed and Nickel for tubes that have leads.
- Tube is retested to manufacture’s original specification or greater.
After that, the tube is sent back to its owner or returned to stock. John mentioned that they are very proud of there vacuum tube processing machines, so I asked if he could send along a picture. They certainly look impressive to me, too:
Vacuum tube processing machine, photo courtesy of ECONCO
Not exactly sure which tube type these are, but they sure to look like 4CX15,000:
Vacuum pump working on rebuilt ceramic power tubes, photo courtesy ECONCO
Econco has been in business since 1968 and rebuilds about 600-1,000 tubes per month. In the past, broadcasters used most of the larger tube types. However, with the majority of broadcast transmitters shifting to solid state, other markets have opened up such as industrial heating, military, research and medical equipment.
I have had problems with Eimac tubes also when the Salt Lake City plant was producing tubes. Some tubes were gassy right out of the box and literally “popped” upon application of plate voltage. The tube was the 8874 triode. Years ago, I also had problems with cathode-poisoning in the Eimac 8560A tetrodes. This is when we looked to Amperex in Hicksville, LI, NY. There was definitely an improvement and we still have Amperex 8560A tubes running beautifully today. When they are gone, they are gone because the Amperex plant on Long Island, I was told is full of weeds and effectively out of business. The quality out of this plant was A-1 in my book. The 5924 triodes were used in the Standard 938 as well as the Rust FMT-5 grounded-grid FM transmitters. My experience with these tubes was excellent and the original tube remained in the 938 right up to the installation of the increased power BTF-20E on 102.9 MHz in 1971. I believe Eimac’s production facilities are now all in California, and the quality has improved greatly. As far as power-grid tube production these days, it is still going fairly strong. Maybe not so for broadcasters, but the medical industry is using many for MRI machines. Apparently the solid state power amplifiers used for this service around 60 MHz. have been somewhat troublesome under continuous usage, and it is back to tubes for the rescue! I was told at the NAB that over 15,000 of these tubes were sold last year. That’s a lot of tubes by any standard, especially at this state of the art.
I have yc 156a tube and I waned 2 no if you all buy to rebuild tubes?